Think you’re doing everything right? These common myths might be raising your kidney stone risk.
When trying to prevent kidney stones, there’s nothing more frustrating than hearing conflicting advice. Should you stop dairy? Is lemon juice a cure-all? Does spinach count as a superfood or a stone-maker? I’ve spent the last 26+ years helping people prevent stones and have heard almost every myth out there.
So, let’s clear things up. Below, I’ve rounded up 50 of the most common kidney stone food and drink myths—busted and broken down into simple categories to make it easy to follow.
Sodium & Salt Myths
MYTH: Salt has nothing to do with kidney stones.
TRUTH: This is false. High sodium increases calcium in your urine, raising your risk for stones. It also decreases urine volume.
MYTH: Sea salt or Himalayan salt is safer than table salt.
TRUTH: Nope. All salt is sodium. The source doesn’t matter to your kidneys.
MYTH: Low-sodium soy sauce is fine for stones.
TRUTH: It’s lower than regular but still salty. Read your labels!
MYTH: I don’t use a salt shaker, so I’m good.
TRUTH: OMG! I hear this all day long while helping patients understand their urine collection results. Just because you took the salt shaker off your table doesn’t mean you eat a low sodium diet. Most sodium comes from processed foods—not your salt shaker.
MYTH: Sodium only matters if I have high blood pressure.
TRUTH: Sodium affects calcium in your urine, even if your blood pressure is normal.
Calcium, Dairy & Supplement Myths
MYTH: I should avoid calcium because my stones are made of calcium.
TRUTH: You need calcium in your diet—it helps bind to oxalate and keeps it out of your urine. And you don’t want osteoporosis! Your bones need calcium!
MYTH: All dairy causes kidney stones.
TRUTH: Not true. Dairy, in the right amounts, helps prevent stones.
MYTH: Cheese is bad for kidney stones.
TRUTH: It depends. Some cheeses are high in sodium, but their calcium content can help. Swiss cheese has the best ratio of sodium vs calcium per slice.
MYTH: I’ll take calcium supplements instead of eating dairy.
TRUTH: Supplements aren’t as effective and can increase stone risk when taken without food. Calcium supplements are NOT recommended. Getting calcium from natural sources is best for bone absorption and stone prevention.
NOTE: if you do not use dairy, use these non dairy options.
Oxalate & Vegetable Myths
MYTH: Oxalate is toxic—I should cut it out completely.
TRUTH: I am on a mission to bring more fruits and veggies back into your diet. When people call me to go over urine collection results, they take out so many healthy foods because they are so anxious about the oxalate part of your Kidney Stone Diet® goals. You don’t need to avoid it; balance it with calcium and remove the high oxalate culprits. Listen to this.
MYTH: All nuts and seeds are bad.
TRUTH: Only some. Almonds, cashews, and chia seeds are high in oxalate; others, like pistachios, sunflower seeds, and macadamias, are safer. Read this.
MYTH: Spinach is a superfood—I eat it every day.
TRUTH: Spinach is one of the highest oxalate foods. Take it off the menu!
MYTH: Almond milk is a healthy milk substitute.
TRUTH: Not for stone formers. It’s higher in oxalate. Use these non dairy milks instead.
MYTH: I have to go plant-based.
TRUTH: No one has to go from eating meat to eating only plants. That is NOT necessary to prevent kidney stones. I have also had patients tell me their doctors told them to stop being plant eaters and go back to eating meat. Not necessary and a lazy way to educate patients.
Hydration & Fluid Myths
MYTH: I drink enough water.
TRUTH: Most people don’t. You should be making 2.5–3 liters of urine per day. I hear this all the time; “Jill, I carry my water bottle everywhere with me!” And my reply is always the same; “Yes, but do you drink from it?” Most of the time, they just laugh and say, “Well Jill…….”
MYTH: All fluids count the same.
TRUTH: All fluids DO count, but water is best. Some drinks add sugar, salt, and oxalate, which increases risk.
MYTH: Soda counts toward hydration.
TRUTH: Soda has too much sugar and doesn’t hydrate you well. Skip it when you can.
MYTH: Iced tea is a good choice.
TRUTH: Black tea is high in oxalate; limit it. Herbal teas are better. Read this.
MYTH: Sports drinks help prevent stones.
TRUTH: Many are loaded with sugar and sodium and can increase your stone risk.
MYTH: If I’m not thirsty, I don’t don’t need more water.
TRUTH: Thirst isn’t a reliable cue. Drink steadily throughout the day.
MYTH: I can drink all my water at night to catch up.
TRUTH: Spread your intake across the day for the best results.
MYTH: Dark urine isn’t a big deal.
TRUTH: It’s a good visual clue that you are not drinking enough. Aim for pale yellow.
Protein & Diet Myths
MYTH: All proteins are the same.
TRUTH: Animal protein increases urine uric acid and calcium and lowers citrate . Limit it by seeing how much is best for you! Read this.
MYTH: I need a lot of meat to be healthy.
TRUTH: Excess meat raises calcium and uric acid in your urine. It also decreases your urine pH and citrate. All stone risk factors. Read this.
MYTH: High-protein diets work for everyone.
TRUTH: Not for stone formers. Balance is everything.
MYTH: Keto helps you lose weight, so it must help with stones.
TRUTH: Keto can increase stone risk—low urine, high acid, and low citrate.
MYTH: Vegetarians don’t get kidney stones.
TRUTH: They can—especially with high oxalate and low calcium intake.
Having a hard time getting enough protein? I am very proud to announce I have made a Kidney Stone Diet Safe protein bar cook e-book! Use the coupon code MAGICBARS to get a special newsletter member discount!
Juice, Vinegar & Citrus Myths
MYTH: Lemonade dissolves kidney stones.
TRUTH: Fresh lemon juice MAY help prevent some stones but doesn’t break up stones unless they are tiny uric acid stones. It will not break up any other stone type.
MYTH: Apple cider vinegar breaks down stones.
TRUTH: It’s trendy but not backed by solid research.
MYTH: Pomegranate juice cures kidney stones
TRUTH: There is no evidence it helps dissolve or prevent stones.
MYTH: Lime water flushes out stones.
TRUTH: It may help with prevention because they contain citrate—but not stone removal.
MYTH: Celery juice cures kidney stones.
TRUTH: It’s hydrating but not a magic cure. Use the searchable oxalate list to see how high celery is in oxalate.
MYTH: Cranberry juice helps all kidney stones.
TRUTH: It may help certain UTIs but doesn’t do anything for kidney stone prevention.
MYTH: Tart cherry juice prevents stones.
TRUTH: No clinical support for that.
MYTH: If juice is organic, it’s safe.
TRUTH: Organic sugar is still sugar. And sugar raises stone risk by raising urine calcium and lowering urine volume. Here are some tips to lower sugar.
MYTH: Citrate in juice replaces potassium citrate.
TRUTH: Citrate from juice rarely reaches the levels needed to replace medication.
Soda, Coffee, & Other Beverage Myths
MYTH: Diet soda is fine because it has no sugar.
TRUTH: It still has phosphoric acid and sodium—both raise stone risk. Listen to this.
MYTH: Clear soda is safer than dark.
TRUTH: Many docs will tell you to drink “clear soda” instead of dark soda. All sodas have too much sugar. Best to, at the very least, cut down on all sodas. The docs say they prefer clear sodas (like Sprite) because they have a bit of citrate in them. There is not enough citrate in clear soda to warrant the advice to drink it. Not a fan.
MYTH: Coffee is dehydrating.
TRUTH: Coffee counts toward hydration in moderation. Here is more on coffee:
MYTH: Decaf doesn’t add to my fluid count.
TRUTH: It certainly does. It’s mostly water. More here:
MYTH: Sparkling water causes kidney stones.
TRUTH: No evidence supports this. If it is plain and without sugar, it’s fine.
Superfood & “Miracle Cure” Myths
MYTH: Watermelon dissolves kidney stones.
TRUTH: Hydrating? Yes. Dissolving? Nope.
MYTH: Chanca piedra will crush all stones
TRUTH: It’s not a proven treatment. Don’t self-medicate without checking with your doctor.
MYTH: Herbal detox teas flush out stones.
TRUTH: Not a fan. Save your nickles and drink water to help stones pass.
MYTH: Eating more fiber will push stones out.
TRUTH: Fiber helps your gut—not your kidney stones
MYTH: There’s a smoothie that melts stones.
TRUTH: Wouldn’t that be great? This is not a thing. Many smoothies are full of oxalate-rich ingredients. I have a whole cookbook with 30 delicious low oxalateKidney Stone Diet® Safe Smoothies. If you buy my kidney stone prevention course, you get it FREE!
Vitamin & Supplement Myths
MYTH: Vitamin C is always safe.
TRUTH: Too much converts into oxalate in your body. Listen to more.
MYTH: Kidney support supplements are safe.
TRUTH: Many are unregulated and may contain risky ingredients. You must still adhere to KSD goals.
Conclusion:
Kidney stone prevention isn’t about being perfect. It’s about knowing what helps—and letting go of all the noise. If you’ve fallen for some of these, you’re not alone. Most of my patients have.
But now you know better. And when you know better, you can eat—and drink—smarter.
Your friend,
Nurse Jill
Leave a Reply