Transcript
Oxalate Content in White Mushrooms
00:00:00 Jeff Sarris
Are mushrooms, garlic, and onions good for kidney stones? Let's talk about that.
Welcome back to the Kidney Stone Diet podcast, the show about reducing your kidney stone risk and living your best life. I'm your host and fellow student, Jeff Sarris.
And I'm Jill Harris, your kidney stone prevention nurse.
So, mushrooms, onions, garlic, are they are they high in oxalate? Like they're so common in so many recipes, but what do we think about them when it comes to kidney stone prevention?
Yeah, right away I think a pizza. And I will say this, I don't like mushrooms. Really, I'm not a big mushroom fan, but I think of a pizza when I when I hear that combination for some reason.
You know, so we have the oxalate food list at kidneystonediet.com. It makes it so easy. This is free to you.
I'm not selling nothing.
And if you just put mushrooms right into the search engine, you'll get all the mushrooms that Harvard studied. And so Harvard studied white mushrooms versus white cooked mushrooms and then soup, cream of mushroom soup, all low.
All low. What's low? Zero, zero, and then the soup is 1.5.
You know, you can have mushrooms. Now, if you're on my Facebook group, people will say, "Oh, my god, but other mushrooms are really high." So, the Facebook group is there's thousands of people on there. So, I'm always on that page.
So, that's Kidney Stone Diet on Facebook.
And here's the thing about mushrooms. We'll get to onion and garlic in a second. The thing about mushrooms is you can see it's been studied before.
There's a lot more mushrooms that Harvard did not study that other people have studied, all right? And what is the source here? I forget what the source was.
Nutrition Journal.
Dried Versus Cooked Mushrooms Oxalate Content
And so they're talking about shiitake, portobello, oyster, chanterelle, porcini mushrooms, very high. Very high. Now, don't click away and think you have your answer because the study says, you know, shiitake mushrooms are 124 mg per
100 g of dry, dry! So, when you're reading these journals, and this comes from the soluble and insoluble oxalate content of mushrooms, this is the Journal of Food Sciences and Nutrition, and dry mushrooms were studied.
So, that's going to have a higher oxalate number than something that has been cooked, okay? So, and that's because there's more water, okay? So, once you have, let me let me explain it to you.
When you see oxalate
Numbers from mushrooms in research, you have to pay attention whether they've been cooked weight or dry weight because mushrooms are about 90% water. So, when researchers remove that water, the oxalate becomes much more concentrated by weight.
So, that means 100 g of dried mushrooms is very different from 100 g of cooked mushrooms. Y'all are eating the cooked mushrooms. Now, some of you, you could say, "I'm eating in a charcuterie board," or whatever they're called, "the meat thing.
I'm eating those in a dip. I'm eating those." I eat dry ones. So, you've got to be careful.
If you're cooking them, they're going to be a lot less oxalate.
So, even though some of these mushrooms are listed as high, you've got to pay attention if they've been cooked or they're dry. If they're dry, they're going to be higher. I don't have a problem with you eating some cooked mushrooms.
Again, portion, not perfection. So,
A shiitake mushroom, let's let me give you a really good example, so you can understand. So, a dry, not cooked, a dry shiitake mushroom per 100 g is 124 mg of oxalate.
So, if you're not paying attention to that, you know, it's dry matter, not cooked, you're like, "Oh, I can't have shiitake mushrooms anymore." Once those shiitake mushrooms are cooked for 100 g, it's 12 1/2 mg of oxalate. So, you can have, you know, a nice little, that's like 8 to 12 shiitake mushrooms. You know, how much more do you need?
So, so you've got to be really careful. If you just put into ChatGPT, or Google, or something, "mushrooms," and it's going to say, "Shiitake: high. Stay away." Now, y'all are taking away mushrooms, or you're only eating button mushrooms cuz Harvard studied them.
Okay, so you've got to really pay attention to what preparation are they giving you oxalate numbers for?
Portion Control and Oxalate Serving Sizes
Now, I actually, this is ironic that Jeff said this is what we're going to talk about today because I had a patient that her oxalate was really high and, you know, she said, "I don't know what I'm eating. I'm I just I don't get it," you know? "Why is it so high?" She happened to be eating, I think it was eight to ten
Pans, pans, like 14-inch pans of mushrooms, okay? So, along with other things that were not high if you ate them in a portion, but when you're eating pans and pans, and she would eat right out of the pan.
You know, you'd be surprised what people do. So, this is why we're always reminding you to the portion not perfection thing because, you know, I can tell you butt- buttons, mushrooms are lower, but I want to be really clear on per serving, this is how much we know them to be. Because once people see that something's high, quote, unquote, they just stop eating it.
That's why we give you the numbers
On the oxalate list. We just don't categorize them high, not high, fine, because then you just it's black and white to you. When you tell a patient you can have 100 mg of oxalate a day, you get your bank account replenished every day, just don't go over that number, then you can see, "Oh, my god, there's so much food you can eat." But you don't want to eat
Garlic and Onions for Stone Prevention
Tons of really low oxalate food because it adds up. So, anyway, you can eat some mushrooms, folks, all in within normal portions. Onion and garlic, enjoy.
Enjoy. Low oxalate foods and, honestly, no one's eating, you know, pans of garlic. You would have no friends, okay?
So, that's not happening. Onions and garlic are absolutely fine to have, especially when you're keeping sodium low as a kidney stone former, as a heart disease patient, as a high blood pressure patient. You want to use these seasonings, right?
So, garlic and onion are so flavorful, and on a low salt diet, they can become a lifesaver.
So, absolutely fine to eat on a lower oxalate diet. Please enjoy them. Mushrooms, I don't have a problem with anybody eating anything that's cooked mushrooms.
If you're looking up different mushrooms that Harvard did not study, you may see them to be very high. If you're eating mushrooms in great quantities dry before cooking, they can add up. So, pay attention to that.
But cooked mushrooms,
You know, four or five mushrooms on a plate, nobody's making a kidney stone because of that. So, please enjoy, not a problem. Onion, garlic, mushrooms, enjoy.
Yeah, and if you're looking for the answers to all of your questions about oxalate, about all of the Kidney Stone Diet prevention goals that will help you prevent future stones, you can go to kidneystonediet.com. And while you're there, check out our all-access pass for meal plans where Jill has made hundreds and hundreds of recipes where every day you get four: breakfast, lunch, snack, and dinner, recipes to inspire your day.
It's how to help you more easily prevent stones without having the paradox of choice. There are so many different options. So, this just lays out a set of options for you for any given week.
Again, that's kidneystonediet.com. And thanks for tuning in, and we'll see you next week.
Bye, everybody. Thank you for being here.